Critique of Valuation Methods for Exploration Properties and Undeveloped Mineral Resources

"Exploration properties form a continuum from grass roots to those with favourable geology, geochemical and/or geophysical anomalies, mineralization, showings (prospects), and finally to those with defined mineral deposits. Often properties exhibit a composite of these categories.The most problematic to value are properties or deposits that are not economically exploitable at the time of the valuation, due to a lack of exploration, insufficient grade or tonnage, poor mining conditions, or the imposition of socioeconomic, environmental, or legal constraints.Various acceptable methods of valuing the range of all such mineral properties or deposits are reviewed. Some inappropriate methods are also discussed.BIOGRAPHYIan S. Thompson is President and Principal of Derry, Michener, Booth & Wahl Consultants Ltd. (DMBW), an independent consulting practice, specializing in exploration, ore reserve estimations, engineering and valuations of mineral properties.Mr. Thompson is a graduate in Honours Geological Sciences from the University of Toronto with over 35 years Canadian and International experience in mineral exploration and development, including the discovery of base metal. gold and uranium deposits.DMBW is affiliated with DMBW, Inc. in Colorado, and works with independent engineering and financial groups in North America, Europe, Australia and Africa.Mr. Thompson is a national member of CIM; the Associations of Professional Engineers of Ontario and British Columbia; The Geological Association of Canada; The Society of Economic Geologists; The Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada and the BC and Yukon Chamber of Mines.INTRODUCTIONThis paper is presented in response to the request of the Mineral Economics Society of the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy for a Review of Approaches to Valuation of Mineral Properties, as recommended by the TSE/OSC Mining Standards Task Force.Exploration properties with undeveloped mineral resources range from grassroots acreage without exploration history, to those containing mineralization (or a mineral resource) that is insufficiently explored, to well explored deposits which lack either continuity, or sufficient grade/tonnage, or have poor mineability or metallurgy, such that they are not currently exploitable at the time of the valuation. This does not imply that they do not have value."