Discussion Of Papers Of Institute Of Metals Division Presented At New York Meeting, February, 1924

CONTENTS PAGE ANDERSON, ROBERT J., and ENOS, GEORGE M.-Corrosion of Brass as Affected by Grain Size. Discussed by Henry S. Rawdon, Robert J. Anderson, Francis B. Coyle, William B. Price, and W. R. Webster 1 RAWDON, HENRYS., and MUTCHLER, WILLARD H.-Effect of Severe Cold Working on Scratch and Brinell Hardness. Discussed by W. H. Bassett, John Livermore Christie, John R. Freeman, Jr., W. R. Webster, William B. Price, Norman B. Pilling, D. J. McAdam, Jr., F. G. Smith, Zay Jeffries, F. E. Carter 3 WILLIAMS, ROBERT S., and HOMERBERG, VICTOR 0.-Relation of Heat Treatment to the Microstructure of 60-40 Brass. Discussed by 0. W. Ellis 14 Corrosion of Brass as Affected by Grain Size Discussion of the paper of ROBERT J. ANDERSON and GEORGE M. ENOS, presented at the New York Meeting, February, 1924, and issued as Paper No. 1282, with MINING AND METALLURGY, December, 1923. HENRY S. RAWDON,* Washington, D. C. (written discussion).-So numerous and so varied are the factors that affect the corrosion of metals that particular care is necessary in corrosion tests to eliminate so far as possible all extraneous factors. It appears to the writer that the question may well be asked as to whether all the necessary precautions have been observed in this investigation. It may be that the points to be mentioned were considered by the authors and found to be insignificant; however, there is nothing in the report to show this.