Lake Superior Paper - Discussion of the paper by Messrs. Lord and Haas on the Calorific Value of Certain Coals (see p. 259)

William Kent, New York City: I regard the paper of Professors Lord and Haas as the most important and valuable that has yet appeared on the subject of the calorific value of American coals. The close correspondence of the results they have obtained by the use of the bomb calorimeter with those calculated by the Dulong formula from the ultimate analyses, confirming the work done by Mahler in France some years before, is evidence of the extreme accuracy of their work, and gives us renewed confidence in Mahler's modification of the Berthelot calorimeter, and in Dulong's formula, which latter, until