New York Paper - Comparative Notes on Steel-Rail Rolling

I have frequently stated that while the chemical composition of steel is important, yet even greater importance is connected with the mechanical and heat treatment of the metal. During the past year I encountered such a positive example of that fact that I deem it worth putting upon record. A prominent railway system divided an order for open-hearth steel rails between two steel works, both of which are under the control of the same corporation; giving to one about 18,000 tons, and to the other 7,500 tons of the same section and to be made under the same specifications. The rolling results obtained in the two mills varied so widely that a study of the figures is intensely interesting and serves to illustrate the advantages obtained by carefu1 ingot casting, and, quite as pertinently, the possible benefits of careful subsequent heating and rolling with moderate reductions in the rolling process. The smaller order was rolled complete in four installments during the same months that the larger order was being made in six separate installments; but, to permit of exact comparisons, the totals of the four installments (completing the order with the mill which I will call A) are given with the totals of the first four installments of the larger order, made by the mill designated as B. These rolling results are: Mill A. Mill B. Number of rollings,............................................ 4 4 Total number of rails rolled................................ 18,278 27,832 Percentage of rails cut to short lengths because of flaws near ends, etc......................................... 0.7 7.6 Percentage of rails made second quality for flaws, etc. 0.9 6.3 Percentage of rails scrapped for flaws, etc............... 0.6 4.5 Percentage of rails scrapped for failure at drop test... none 3.4 It should be stated that the figures given above cover all the reasons for putting the rails in the classes stated, Thus a part of the percentage of rails cut to short lengths may have been