Search Documents

By J. Nell

Heavy mineral deposits often contain relatively high levels of radioactive elements (thorium and uranium in particular).It is difficult to obtain clean separation of ilmenite and monazite (the main impurity mineral containing radioactive elements), and physical intergrowths of the two minerals are, in fact, not uncommon. As a result, ilmenite concentrates obtained from such deposits often contain high levels of thorium and uranium. Because of the large negative free energies of formation of ThO2and U3O8boththorium and uranium report to the slag during smelting and if an ilmenite concentrate contaminated with monazite is used to make high titania slag, the concentrations of these elements in the slag end up about 40% higher than in the ilmenite feed. Previous work, patented by RGC Mineral Sands Limited, and subsequently confirmed by Mintek, showed that radioactivity may be reduced by roasting an ilmenite concentrate with borax at 1000°C to 1100°C and leaching it with hydrochloric acid1. It is evident that the cost of an ilmenite roast/leach process will be high and there may be economic benefits in removing the radioactive elements from the slag instead (the volume of slag to be treated is smaller than the volume of ilmenite feed). To remove radioactive elements from the slag it is necessary to know how these elements occur in the slag. Inother words, the distribution of uranium and thorium between the various oxide, silicate and metallic phases in high titania slag must be determined. Once the deportment of thorium and uranium between the various phases ha sbeen determined, an appropriate process for slag purification can be developed. Test samples High-titania slag was prepared in a pilot-scale DC furnace from ilmenite concentrates with different levels of uranium and thorium. Subsequently, ten slag samples representing a range of compositions were selected for bulk chemical analysis, scanning electron microscopy and micro-analysis. The samples were crushed to a maximum particle size of 1 mm and from each sample a 20-kg batch was riffled out for analysis. Bulk chemical composition Chemical compositions of the samples selected for test work are given in Table I. TiO2, Al2O3, SiO2, MgO, MnO, FeO and V2O5were analysed by ICP-OES, Na2O, CaO andCr2O3by atomic absorption spectroscopy and U and Th by XRF (the XRF detection limit for U and Th was around 4 ppm). The ?B? series has a higher silica content than the others as a result of small silica additions that were made during smelting. All samples have elevated alumina levels as a result of furnace refractory contamination during smelting. As expected, there is an inverse relationship between the concentrations of TiO2and FeO in the samples (Figure 1).The TiO2and FeO levels are similar to the levels found in industrial slags2. Extreme conditions of reduction under which reduction of more ?refractory? oxides (e.g., chromia, magnesia, silica, alumina and even urania and thoria) might take place were not explored in the study. Note that BB1and BBB1 contain more than 7% combined silica and alumina (SiO2as a flux addition during smelting, and Al2O3from refractory contamination) and they do not fall on the general trend defined by the other samples. The U and Th concentrations of sample E2 is noteworthy. In the preparation of slag E2, monazite concentrate was added to the ilmenite to increase the concentrations of radioactive elements in the slag. This was done primarily to facilitate the detection of Th and U during the phase chemical characterization of the slag. Radioactivity measurements Gamma ray emissions from the samples were measured [ ]

Jan 1, 2007

O.F.S. Branch Proceedings of the Annual General Meeting on Wednesday, 30th July, 1975 The Aromal General Meeting of the Branch was held at the St. Helena Club on Wednesday, 30th July, 1975 at 7.45 p.m. Mr D. A. Smith (Chairman) was in the Chair. There was also present: Professor R. P. Plewman, President of the S.A. Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. Conference on Vacuum Metallurgy The Fifth International Conference on Vacuum Metallurgy is to be held in Munich from 11th to 15th October, 1976. Excavation and tunnelling A conference on 'Rapid Excavation and Tunneling' is to be held in Las Vegas from 14th to 17th June, 1976. Book reviews Mine filling. Queensland (Australia), Mt. Isa Mines, Limited, ] 973. 293 pp. $A20,00 incl. postage. Young, R. S. Cheml:cal phase analysis. London, Charles Griffin, 1974. 126 pp. £4.50. NIM reports Report no. 1714 The efficiency of the fire-assay procedure with nickel sulphide as the collector in the determination of platinum,silver, gold, and iridium. Report no. 1721 A preliminary investigation into the mechanism of depression in the flotation of sulphide minerals at the Prieska Copper Mine. Report no. 1725 The determination of silica in fluorspar by 14 Me V neutron-activation analysis. Report no. 1736 The determination, by atomic- absorption spectrophotometry and liquid extraction, of antimony (parts per million) in ores and concentrates. Report no. 1741 South African costs of equipment for the metall'urgical industry(1975}. Report no. 1744 The refining of the platinum-group metals . Report no. 1746 The determination, by atomic-absorption spectrophotometry, of minor elements in zinc, lead, and copper sulphide concentrates. Report no. 1747 Magnetohydrostatic separation of gold from gravity concentrates. Report no. 1750 A review of the present and future development of sulphur production in South Africa. Report no. 1754 A new three-dimensional anodic electrode for reduced power consumption du,ring the electrowinning of metals. Report no. 139 A preliminary survey of goldrecovery problems arising in the production of pyrite. (9th Feb., 1967, re-issued Jun. 1975.) 16 pp. Report no. 140 A preliminary mineralogical investigation of pyrite from the K imberley and the Main Reefs, VogelstruisbuU Gold Mine. (13th Feb., 1967, re-issued Jut 1975.) 11 pp. Report no. 165 Gold recovery from pyrite flotation mill products by cyanidation. Progress made up to 1st May, 1967. (5th May, 1967, re-issued Jun. 1975.) 8 pp. Report no. 133 Gold recovery by cyanidation from mill products obtained after pyrite flotation. Progress made up to ht July, 1967. (18th Jul., 1967, reissued Jun. 1975.) 14 pp. Report no. 219 A review of some of the mineralogical factors influencing the flotation of pyrite. (29th Nov., 1967 reissued Jun. 1975.) 20 pp. Report no. 278 Gold recovery by cyanidation from mill products obtained after pyrite flotation. (24th Jan., 1968, re-issued Sep. 1975.) 51 pp. Report no. 306 The effect of preaeration on two samples of thickener under flow from the Venterspost Gold Mine. (30th Mar., 1968, re-issued Jul. 1975.) 14 pp. Report no. 317 Results of tests carried out at the Loraine Gold Mine during the period 5th to 7th February, 1968. (21st Mar., 1968, re-issued Jul. 1975.) 11 pp. Report no. 321 Aeration of ore from the Loraine Gold Mine before theaddition of cyanide.(17th Apr., 1968, reissued Jul. 1975.) 30 pp. Report no. 380 The effect of aeration, before cyanidation, of pulps of gold ores containing xanthate. (14th Aug., 1968, re-issued Jul. 1975.) 44 pp.

Jan 10, 1975

By C. H. Wyndham, N. B. Strydom

INTRODUCTION Acclimatization of the labour force to heat is an integral aspect of gold mining in South Africa. A recent survey revealed that about 250,000 Bantu mine workers require to be acclimatized to heat each year. Until 1965 men were acclimatized by means of one of the Chamber of Mines methods (introduced by the Human Sciences Laboratory in 1953). This type of acclimatization was carried out underground where men shovelled rock in hot stopes under careful supervision. However, it has become increasingly difficult in the last few years for mines to provide underground the conditions of work and environmental heat required for adequate acclimatization to heat. In examining an alternative to acclimatization in underground hot stopes, the Human Sciences Laboratory carried out a trial in 1965 of acclimatization in an air-conditioned climatic room on the surface of a mine. The new procedures developed from this trial have been so successful that there are today 26 climatic rooms on different mines. These rooms have been built following a design proposed by Mr Hodgson of the National Mechanical Engineering Research Institute1. Approximately 85 per cent of the total number of men being acclimatized each year are put through the new procedures in these climatic rooms. This paper gives an account of the problems which arose and how they were solved, the inter-relationship between physical conditioning and climatic room acclimatization, the prodecures developed for elimination of labourers with low maximum oxygen intakes, and the advantages of climatic room acclimatization. CLIMATIC ROOMS The majority of the climatic rooms (twenty) have been built on the surface, but a number (six) of mines preferred to establish their acclimatization centres underground in order to decrease the initial costs involved in the construction of such facilities. These underground climatic rooms are usually located near shaft stations in redundant haulages and they can accommodate from 200 to 400 labourers, thus eliminating the need for multiple acclimatization shifts. Figs. 1-4 illustrate various aspects of a surface climatic room. PROBLEMS WHICH AROSE IN INTRODUCING CLIMATIC ROOM ACCLIMATISATION There were four main problems which arose in connection with the introduction of the new method. These were: (i) The type and rate of work to be used. (ii) The air conditions required to obtain optimum acclimatization. (iii) The duration of exposure to heat each day and the total number of days of acclimatization. (iv) The methods of cooling labourers with high body temperatures. Shovelling rock would have been the desirable type of physical work to employ, but the air-conditioned space required to accommodate large numbers of men and the difficulty in standardizing the work rate in shovelling led to the decision to employ instead the work procedure used by the Human Sciences Laboratory in acclimatizing men in the Laboratory. This is the lifting of the body weight against gravity when men step on and off a bench. It has the advantage that large numbers of men can work physically at the required rate in a relatively small space (120 men can be accommodated in an area of 70 ft by 21 ft) and the cost of construction and ventilation of the climatic rooms is thereby reduced. Also the work rate can be standardized by varying the height of the stepping benches in relation to the individuals' body weights. The next problem was the air condition to be used in the climatic rooms. The Laboratory's research experience in acclimatization led it to choose an air temperature of 89°F (with the air almost saturated with water vapour) and an average velocity of air movement of 100 fpm. This air condition was combined with a work rate of 1,560 ft lb/min (oxygen consumption 1.0 litre/min) on day 1, and the work rate was increased gradually over the period of acclimatization to reach a work rate of 3,120 ft lb/min (oxygen consumption 1.6 litres/min) on day 9.

COUNCIL The following served on Council during the year under review: Office bearers: Prof D. D. Howat (President), Dr J. P. Hugo and P. W. J. van Rensburg (Vice-Presidents), V. C. Robinson (Immediate Past President) and D. G. Maxwell (Honorary Treasurer). Ordinary Members of Council: H. P. Carlisle, R. C. Espley-Jones, G. H. Grange, Dr D. I. Legge, W. W. Malan, Prof R. P. Plewman, Dr R. E. Robinson, Dr M. D. G. Salamon, L. W. P. van den Bosch and P. A. von Wielligh. Branch Chairmen: A. Bain (Witbank-Middelburg Branch), J. M. Meyer (O.F.S. Branch). Past Presidents serving on Council: R. J. Adamson, M. Barcza, H. Britten, H. E. Cross, J. K. E. Douglas, R. C. J. Goode, P. Lambooy, Prof J. de V. Lambrechts, Dr J. T. McIntyre, J. F. Reid and H. Simon (until March 1972). Ten Council meetings were held during the year with an average attendance of nineteen, and the standing committees held 27 meetings. FINANCE The annual accounts which are attached to this report show an excess of income over expenditure of R21 519. It is very gratifying to be able to report that Council's efforts to stop the depletion of our accumulated funds are meeting with success. The most important contributors to our surplus this year are symposia and colloquia, sales of publications, Company Affiliate subscriptions and the profit on the journal. While we do not expect continued profits from all these sources in the future we do feel that we are now in the process of accumulating a substantial financial foundation. This will give the Council the necessary confidence to initiate the new developments in the activities of the Institute which are now under consideration. The decision to create a new grade of membership, Company Affiliate, is dealt with elsewhere in this report. There has been a generous initial response from companies and this is the cornerstone of our improved financial expectations. The MacArthur Forrest Memorial Fund shows an excess of income over expenditure of R91 and the total fund was, therefore, increased by this amount to R4 502. The balance sheet shows that the market value of quoted shares and debentures increased during the year from R9 160 to RH 331, which is R2 134 in excess of the book value. Accumulated funds now amount to RH 529 compared with R23 010 a year ago. MEMBERSHIP Sixteen Fellows, twenty Members, six Graduates, nine Associates, twelve Students and twenty-four Company Affiliates were elected during the year. One Member and two Associates were reinstated. Twelve members were admitted to retired membership. Transfers: Member to Fellow, three. Graduate to Member, seven Associate to Fellow, one. Student to Member, one. Student to Graduate, four. Student to Fellow, one. Your Council records with deep regret the death during the year of the following: Dr A. J. Orenstein (Honorary Life Fellow), R. A. Cooper, R. J. Spargo, H. Simon and F. Meyer (Life Fellows), S. D. Loxton, W. P. Arnold, G. C. Needham, W. G. Pyne-Mercier, J. Innes and O. T. Wright (Fellows), E. P. Mennell and O. B. Prentis (Members), J. Brits (Associate). After careful consideration of all the implications it was decided during the year to create a new grade of membership to be known as Company Affiliate, in order that there might be a formal and permanent channel for companies to contribute to the important work of the Institute. As recorded above, 24 companies had joined by the end of the year and many further applications have been received since. We extend a hearty welcome to all our new members. A comparative statement of membership as at 30th June, 1972, and the end of the previous year is shown in the following tabulation:-

By D. Duncanson, R. J. Davidson, C. G. S. Schmidt, G. A. Brown, J. D. Taylor, N. W. Hanf

The development of a cyanidation route for the treatment of gold-plant gravity concentrates is described. This work was carried out as a natural consequence of earlier improvements to the recovery of gold in the gravity sections of existing gold plants. Concern about the environmental aspects of the conventional amalgamation process was further motivation in the development of an alternative procedure. It was found that the partial pressure of oxygen in solution was the most critical reactionrate determining factor. The rate of gold dissolution was shown to be controlled by the reaction rate below approximately 25°C and by diffusion above that temperature. Thus, the efficiency of pulp agitation and oxygen partial pressure permitted a high degree of control over the rate of gold dissolution. The use of oxygen rather than air significantly increased the dissolution rate of both gold and silver. The solubilities of sodium, calcium, and potassium aurocyanide complexes under simulated reaction conditions were studied, and it was established that the values for the sodium and calcium complexes were limited, requiring the use of lower pulp densities and higher reaction temperatures for the treatment of very high-grade concentrates. The presence of excessive amounts of tramp iron in such concentrates of up to 25 per cent by mass was found to result in poor gold dissolution owing to the cementation of gold under certain reaction conditions. The maintenance of high oxygen partial pressures, together with high cyanide concentrations, high pH levels, and the presence of calcium in the system, all aided in passivating the tramp iron. Copper, gold, and iron were shown to be the main cyanide-consuming elements. Optimum gold dissolution was obtained in a closed bench-scale reactor incorporating a flotation-machine type of agitator for effective pulp agitation and oxygenation, the oxygen being recirculated. The reactor was designed to operate under a very small positive pressure. After reaction times of 2 to 6 hours at temperatures in the region of 30°C, both the gold and the silver dissolution averaged 99,S per cent. In the case of very high-grade concentrates, it was shown that gold could be floated in the same reactor by drawing off the flotation concentrate through a port in the reactor. A flotation recovery of 87,4 per cent of the gold in 3,9 per cent by mass was obtained. The recovery of osmiridium from cyanide-leach residues and the electrowinning of gold from the pregnant liquors were also considered as processing aspects in the treatment of gold-plant belt concentrates. Final table tailings with a gold concentration of 10to 12 gft were obtained. The results of the investigation strongly suggested that an alternative cyanidation route for the treatment of gold-plant concentrates was technically feasible, provided the system included effective agitation and oxygenation. In the case of lower-grade concentrates, cyanidation followed by the electrowinning of gold appears to be the simplest route, while, for high-grade concentrates, flotation and smelting of the concentrate followed by cyanidation of the flotation tailings are suggested. The use of oxygen rather than air for sparging the pulp would depend largely on the grade of material to be treated. A preliminary comparison of the costs related to the amalgamation and cyanidation processes for the recovery of gold from such concentrates indicated very similar capital and operating costs. It was concluded that other considerations, e.g. toxicity, safety, and lower labour requirements, were more important than such small cost differences. Furthermore, the 'opening' of the gold-plant gravity circuit, which would be made possible by a cyanidation route, would further reduce the operating costs because of the subsequent decrease in the tonnage to be treated.

Jan 1, 1978

2nd CONGRESS OF THE INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR ROCK MECHANICS The 2nd Congress of the International Society for Rock Mechanics will be held in Belgrade, 21-26 September, 1970. The Congress will include: working sessions, study tours, receptions, excursions introduced in the working sessions and post-congress excursions and special programme for accompanying persons. Anyone interested in rock mechanics and its applicarion may take part in the 2nd Congress. Official languages of the Congress are: English, French and German. Simultaneous translation service will be provided during the Congress. All the correspondence concerning the 2nd Congress of the International Society for Rock Mechanics should be addressed to: Sekretarijat 2. kongresa Medjunarodnog drustva za mehaniku stena Institut za vodoprivredu "Jaroslav Cerni" Bulevar vojvode Misica 43, Postanski fah 530 Beograd - Jugoslavija NINTH INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM TECHNIQUES FOR DECISION MAKING IN THE MINERAL INDUSTRY The Symposium which is to be held in Montreal during the week of June 14-19, 1970, follows the Computer Symposium held in Salt Lake City this year. The purpose of the Symposium is to define the role of decision making techniques within the mineral industry and to stimulate the development of specific applications. The subject of the Symposium-mathematics, operations research and computers as applied to the mineral industry-allows a complete picture of the mineral industry in its public policy, corporate, financial and technological environment to emerge. This is another of the series of symposia on this and related subjects started in the early 1960's at the University of Arizona. Sponsorship has included a number of Universities and the Society of Mining Engineers of the American Institute of Mining. This 1970 symposium is the first to be held outside of America, and is being sponsored by the Canadian Institute of Mining, McGill University and Ecole Polytechnique. A number of delegates from South Africa have participated in these symposia and several have already arranged to attend this symposium in Montreal. Enquiries should be directed to: Secretariat, The 9th International Symposium, Department of Mining Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique, P.O. Box 50l, Snowden, Montreal 248, Quebec, Canada. 24th INTERNATIONAL GEOLOGICAL CONGRESS This Congress is to be held in Montreal, Canada, from August 21 to 30, 1972. A very detailed and extensive programme has been proposed, and includes a number of excursions. Copies of the first circular are obtainable from: The Organizing Committee, 24th International Geological Congress, 601 Booth Street, Ottawa 4, Ontario, CANADA. SYMPOSIUM ON THE RECOVERY OF PYRITE The proceedings of the Symposium on the Recovery of Pyrite, held in Johannesburg on 12th to 13th June 1969 are now available. Copies may be ordered from the Secretary, S.A.I.M.M., P.O. Box 61019, Marshalltown, Transvaal at a cost of R10.00. Papers and addresses presented at the Symposium were: Opening Address by Mr J. K. E. Douglas (President). 'The world sulphur position,' by W. C. J. van Rensburg (Member). 'The South African sulphur position,' by D. L. Taylor (Member). 'The recovery of pyrite at Government Gold Mining Areas Limited,' by R. J. Westwood (Member), G. S. Stander (Affiliate) and H. R. Carlisle (Member). 'Recovery of pyrite concentrates from colliery-waste discards-A preliminary assessment,' by W. A. Gilbert (Visitor) and E. A. Nugent (Member). 'The role of pyrite in upgrading the uranium content of Witwatersrand conglomerate ores by means of the heavy-medium separation process,' by D. J. Tutt (Associate Member). 'Pyrite recovery by jigs at Durban Roodepoort Deep Limited,' by E. J. Dominy (Affiliate), F. Diamond (Affiliate) and A. D. Graham (Affiliate). 'The storage of pyrite concentrates,' by Joan C. Campkin (Visitor) and P. J. Lloyd (Member). 'The flotation plants of the Anglo- Transvaal Group,' by L. A. Bushell (Member). 'Pyrite flotation with amines and cyanidation of the products,' by E. H. D. Carman (Member). 'Gold recovery by cyanidation from mill products obtained after pyrite flotation,' by P. G. Mrkusic (Graduate), M. Sciarone (Visitor) and H. E. Simonsen (Visitor). 'The influence of sulphydral and cationic flotation reagents on cyanidation of native gold,' by K. G. Ashurst (Visitor) and W. P. Finkelstein (Member). 'Laboratory tests on the flotation of pyrite from Witwatersrand gold ores by cationic collector,' by J. Levin (Member), and M. L. Veitch (Visitor). Closing Address, by Dr R. E. Robinson (Director, National Institute for Metallurgy).

The March General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg on 18th March, 1970, at 4.30 p.m. Mr J. K. E. Douglas (President) was in the Chair. There were also present fifteen Fellows, Messrs H. Britten, R. C. J. Goode, Prof D. D. Howat, Mr T. C. A. Meyer, Dr R. E. Robinson, Messrs V. C. Robinson and P. W. J. van Rensburg (Council Members), S. K. de Kok, Dr N. P. Finkelstein, Messrs K. W. Findlay, H. N. Hepker, J. Levin, Dr K. A. Murray and Mr A. H. Mokken. Four Members including Mr D. Ayres, Dr M. I. Britten and Dr A. Granville. One Associate: Mr G. S. Stander. One Student, Mr R. N. Guest. Four Visitors, Messrs S. A. Allison, C. N. Leibb, C. J. Kooij and A. Mavrogordato. Secretary: Mr D. C. Visser. Total present: Twenty-seven. OBITUARY The President: "It is my sad duty to announce the death of Henrik Johannes Van Eck, Honorary Life Member, who joined the Institute in 1929 and passed away on 18th February, 1970. Dr van Eck started life as a chemist and chemical engineer and, as we all know, he rose to become one of our most distinguished leaders of industry in the country. On many important occasions we, in this Institute, have been privileged to have him address us on subjects which were always of great importance and relevance to the developments in this country. He was a man of great vision and imagination and could put across his ideas in a most eloquent and convincing manner. In his important position as chairman of the Industrial Development Corporation and of Iscor, whatever he said carried great weight. Busy as he was he always found time to participate not only in the affairs of this Institute but in many other technical and public bodies. His passing is a great loss to South Africa and we in this Institute wish to associate ourselves with the many other tributes which have been paid to this great man. We extend our sympathy to his wife and family and as a mark of respect I would ask you to rise and observe a few moments silence." MEMBERSHIP The President: "I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the undermentioned candidates, having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: Fellow: Ian Douglas Bruce Corner, Joachim Bernhard Rolfes. Member: Michael Vernon Nolan. Associate: Karl Franz Wilhelm Eick. MEMBERS TRANSFERRED TO A HIGHER GRADE From Member to Fellow: Nilo Zolezzi. From Graduate to Member: Roger Billingham. I welcome the newly elected members to the Institute and congratulate the members who have been transferred to a higher grade." PAPERS FOR PRESENTATION The President: (i) "Mr Lee, may I call on you to deliver your paper entitled 'A new bubble pick-up technique as a rapid flotation test method'." After the presentation of the paper the President said: "The paper which Mr Lee introduced this afternoon was a short one but was nonetheless important in that it described a new tool for use in flotation test work. Those of us who have experienced the frustration of trying to solve flotation problems by trial and error methods know what this means. I well remember 25 years ago at T.G.M.E. trying to improve the recovery from the flotation plant there by trying various combinations of reagents and then having to wait a couple of days for the assay office to give results. Even then, on the small scale laboratory tests which had to precede full scale tests one could never be sure that the results obtained were reproducible on the full scale. Here it seems we have a relatively simple apparatus which can measure instantly the effectiveness of various reagents under different concentrations and pH values, etc. It is most important, I believe, that developments of this kind be reported in our journal for the benefit of all involved in such work, not only so that we know about it but also in order to provoke constructive discussion which might lead to further developments. I would like to invite members, therefore, to submit papers or notes on important

COUNCIL AND STANDING COMMITTEES - 1973-1974 Office Bearers: P. W. J. van Rensburg (President), Professor R. P. Plewman and Dr R. E. Robinson (Vice Presidents), J. K. E. Douglas (Honorary Treasurer), and Dr J. P. Hugo (Immediate Past President). Elected Members of Council: Dr M. G. Atmore, G. H. Grange, Dr P. R. Jochens, J. G. Kirchner, Dr D. I. Legge, W. W. Malan, Dr M. D. G. Salamon, L. W. P. van den Bosch, D. A. Viljoen, P. A. von Wielligh. Branch Chairmen: B. T. Hosking (Witbank-Middelburg Branch), E. T. Wilson (Orange Free State Branch). Past Presidents Serving on Council: R. J. Adamson, M. Barcza, H. Britten, H. E. Cross, Professor J. de V. Lambrechts, R. C. J. Goode, Professor D. D. Howat, D. M. Jamieson, D. G. Maxwell, Dr J. T. McIntyre, V. C. Robinson. Ten Council meetings were held during the year, with an average attendance of 19, and the standing committees held 30 meetings. COMMITTEE CHAIRMEN Membership, Dr R. E. Robinson ; Metallurgical Colloquia, Dr R. E. Robinson ; Mining Colloquia, L. W. P. van den Bosch; Awards, P. W. J. van Rensburg; Excursions, P. A. von Wielligh; Dinner, G. H. Grange ; Constitution, Rules and Policy, Dr J. P. Hugo; Adjudicating, P. W. J. van Rensburg; Mines and Works, W. W. Malan; Education, Dr J. P. Hugo. REPRESENTATIVES ON OTHER BODIES Associated Scientific and Technical Societies: Members : V. C. Robinson and D. G. Maxwell Alternates : P. W. J. van Rensburg and Dr J. P. Hugo. Federation of Societies of Professional Engineers Members : J. K. E. Douglas and P. W. J. van Rensburg Alternates : Dr J. P. Hugo and G. H. Grange. South African Council for Professional Engineers Members : R. C. J. Goode and J. K. E. Douglas Alternates: G. H. Grange and Dr R. E. Robinson. Engineers' Liaison Committee (Pretoria): Member: Professor J. de V. Lambrechts Alternate : Dr J. P. Hugo. MEMBERSHIP Seventeen Fellows and Members, twenty-three Graduates, ten Associate Members, twenty-two Associates, thirty-four Students, and seven Company Affiliates were elected during the year. Eleven Fellows and four Members were admitted to retired membership. Five Fellows were elected to Honorary Life Membership. Four Members, two Graduates, and one Student were transferred to Fellows ; eleven Graduates and Students were transferred to Members ; eight Students to Graduates; and four Students to Associates. A statement of membership as at June 30th 1974 and the end of the previous year is given in the following tabulation 30th - 30th June, - June, 1973 - 1974 Honorary Life Fellows 4 - 9 Honorary Fellows 9 - 8 Life Fellows 177 - 170 Fellows 536 - 544 Members 487 - 512 Associate Members - - 10 Graduates 128 - 130 Associates 186 - 194 Students 183 - 173 Company Affiliates 64 - 70 1 774 - 1 820 OBITUARIES Your Council records with deep regret the death during the year of the following members : Dr P. N. Lategan and Dr O. A. Jackson, Honorary Life Fellows and Past Presidents; C. Airth, T. L. Blunt, J. B. Dennison, A. E. Frazer, C. L. Lamb, V. O. Reid, K. Richardson and D. G. Roberts, Life Fellows ; H. F. Allan, J. T. Beaumont, M. Eisenstein, J. C. Hall, C. F. Louw, H. H. McGregor, R. Murchison, and J. E. Williamson, Fellows; and R. B. Miles, Associate. FINANCE The annual accounts, which follow this report, reflect a healthy position and show that measures taken by Council over the last few years to boost income have been successful. A higher income was needed not only to meet rising costs but also so that the services provided by the Institute for its members could be expanded. This year's income of R55 025 showed a further increase compared with last year's figure of R48 307. Income from subscriptions was higher mainly owing to an increased number of Company Affiliates, and this is indicative of the support given by mining and metallurgical companies to the good work being done by the Institute. Further sales of publications of the symposia held over the last few years again made a useful contribution to income of R4560. The first Winter School held in 1973 yielded a surplus of R7495 after the expenses had been deducted from the income received from registration fees. The cost of administering the Institute increased by R2212 compared with the previous year. Included in this was a donation of R1000 to the A.S. & T.S. Trust Fund. The cost of publishing and printing the Journal increased by R2034, but advertising and extraneous sales of the Journal were higher, with the result that the net cost of the

Jan 10, 1974

A Colloquium and General Meeting were held on 17th March 1971, the theme being 'Future trends in steel production'. Mr V. C. Robinson (President) was in the Chair. The Colloquium was attended by 121 delegates and was opened by the President at 10 a.m. OBITUARIES THE PRESIDENT: 'It is my sad duty to announce the death of the following: F. O. Read, Fellow, who joined the Institute in 1957 and passed away on 13th January, 1971. P. G. M. May, Member, who joined the Institute in 1969 and passed away on 10th August, 1970. R. J. J. Rademeyer, Life Fellow, who joined the Institute in 1942 and passed away on 23rd September, 1970. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased and in sympathy with the bereaved I would ask you all to rise and observe a few moments silence. CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES THE PRESIDENT: 'May we confirm the minutes of the monthly general meeting held on 21st October and 18th November, 1970, as published in the Journal'. Agreed. MEMBERSHIP THE PRESIDENT: 'I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the undermentioned candidates, having been published in accordance with ByLaw 5.2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: FELLOWS: Romain August Lathioor, Paolo Piga, Renato Ribacchi, Willem Frederick Jacobus Smith, Matthew Churchill, Thomas Anthony James Braithwaite, Hugh Patrick Hart, Eleanor Innocentius Muller, David Alton Smith. MEMBERS: Douglas Adendorff, Petrus Jacob du Plooy, James Valentine Grant Middleton, Karl Anders Ullerstam, Josephus Theodorus Johannes van Wyk, Frank Douglas Abbott. GRADUATES: David Mervyn Gilbart-Smith, John Philip Wilcocks Bennie, Hendrik Theunis Burger, Johann Wilhelm Coetzee, Johannes Stephanus StOols, Leon van Tonder, Brian George Harvey, John Kennedy McLean. ASSOCIATES Richard Cyril Lee Stoyell, Terrence Brian Gouws, Alister Rodney Frederick MacDonald. STUDENTS: Andries Groenewald, Christiaan Johannes Hattingh, William Hendrik Hofmeyr, Stanley Thomas Vincent. I welcome the new members to the Institute and congratulate them on their election. COLLOQUIUM The President welcomed everyone present and mentioned that this was the first of the Colloquia which are to replace the Institute's monthly meetings. He stressed that discussion at Colloquia would be completely informal and would not be recorded unless the contributor requested publication. In conclusion, he thanked the organising committee, the authors and the contributors, and introduced the author of the first paper. The following papers were presented:- 'The future development of the Iron and Steel Industry' by J. P. Coetzee (Published in the Journal March 1971). Among those who contributed to the paper were Dr Bleloch, Dr K. Gebhard, Dr Way and Professor Müller. The main point made by Dr Bleloch related to the reserves of coking coal and of coal for power generation this in country and he deduced that in South Africa we are critically short of coking coal. On the basis that 4 million tons per year of coking coal are consumed for our present steel production, over 16 million tons would be required to meet the anticipated expansion in steel output by A.D. 2000. This must be set against the grim forecast made by the Coal Advisory Board in 1967 that our national reserves of coking coal will be exhausted before A.D. 2000. This gives tremendous significance to the development work presently being carried out by Iscor on alternative methods for coke production. On the other hand the blast furnace may have to be replaced by an alternative process for the reduction of iron ores, e.g., the use of rotary kilns followed by electric arc smelting. Dr Bleloch also expressed grave forebodings about the reserves of bituminous coal, pointing out that with present methods of mining the recoverable coal in any given reserve is in general only 50 per cent of that reserve. He stated that in the past seventy years great quantities of coal have been forever placed beyond the reach of mining by being undermined by extraction of lower seams or lost by being burned. A final point made by Dr Bleloch was the fast rise in the capital investment in a fully integrated steel plant, the figure having risen in the past decade from just over R200 to R350 per ton of finished steel per annum. Dr Gebhard spoke of the direct reduction processes for iron making pointing out the difficulties of securing a high percentage of reduction and the relatively high cost of smelting in electric arc furnaces. As an alternative he suggested briquetting the high carbon sponge iron

The Annual General Meeting of the South African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on Wednesday, 27th August, 1975. Professor R. P. Plewman (President) was in the Chair. There were present 45 Fellows, 37 Members, 8 Graduates, 3 Associates, 4 Students, and 45 Visitors, making a total of 142. The President declared the Meeting open at 16h00. OBITUARIES The President: Ladies and gentlemen, it is my sad duty to announce the death of the following members of the Institute : M. Barcza, an Honorary Life Fellow and Past President of the Institute; J. A. Boyd, F. E. Keep, and J. H. Taylor, Life Fellows ; I. D. B. Corner, C. O'G. Deane, R. E. Gilmour, A. C. Hofmeyr, M. W. Howell, T. J. Robin, and F. S. Steinhobel, Fellows; J. J. Frankel, Member; and T. J. Higgs, Associate. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased and in sympathy with the bereaved, I ask you to rise and observe a few moments' silence. MINUTES The President: May we confirm the minutes of the General Meeting held on March 12th 1975 and published in the June issue of the Journal? Agreed. WELCOME The President: It is now my very great pleasure to welcome the many members of our Institute and all the distinguished guests who have honoured us with their presence this afternoon. In particular, I would like to welcome our Honorary President, Mr R. S. Lawrence, President of the Chamber of Mines, and also our Honorary Vice-President, Mr T. L. Gibbs, the Government Mining Engineer. Ons is ook besonder vereer dat dr. Naude, die Wetenskaplike Raad-gewer aan die Eerste Minister, en mnr. C. A. J. Borman, Direkteur van die Witwatersrandse Kollege vir Gevorderde Tegniese Onderwys, hier aanwesig is om die vergadering by to woon. We are also honoured by the presence of some 19 Presidents, Vice-Presidents, and Chairmen of our sister scientific and technical organizations. I would particularly like to welcome Mr Gericke of the South African Council for Professional Engineers, Professor Pretorius of the A.S. & T.S., and Dr Lloyd of F.S.P.E. And then, also the Presidents of the Institute of Welding, Professor Robinson; of the Electrical Engineers, Dr Troost ; of the Certificated Mechanical and Electrical Engineers, Mr Gibbs; of the Geological Society, Professor Maske; of the Land Surveyors of the Transvaal, Mr Course ; of the Assayers and Analysts, Mr Williams; of the Mine Ventilation Society, Mr Martinson; of the Chemical Institute, Mr Goodman; of the Association of Mine Managers, Mr Pretorius ; of the Institute of Foundrymen, Mr Attenborough; of the Production Engineers, Mr Duggan ; and of S.A.F.U.E.S., Mr Avalle. Then, the Chairman of the Council of the Institute of Metallurgists, Mr Snow; the Vice-President of the Town and Regional Planning, Mr Reinecke; the Vice-President of the Association of Consulting Engineers, Mr O'Kell; and Mr Cronje, who is representing E.A.S.A. Finally, the Chairman of the Southern Transvaal Section of the Chemical Institute, Mr Bloom ; the Chairman of the Witbank-Middelburg Branch of our own Institute, Mr Hosking; and the Secretary-Treasurer of our O.F.S. Branch, Mr Bird. We also have with us Mr Trueman; the Deputy Manager of Kelvin House, Mr Mrost ; our Honorary Editor, Dr Glen; Mr Walford; and also some representatives of the Press. Finally, it gives me great pleasure to welcome those who will receive Honorary Life Fellowships tonight, and also the winners of our student prizes. MEMBERSHIP The President: Ladies and gentlemen, I have pleasure in announcing the names of the following candidates, which have been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.5., and Council has elected them to membership in the following grades: Fellows: R. G. Boswell, R. W. Chadwick, D. R. Hardman, J. A. Holmes, T. J. B. Jones, and R. P. King. Members : M. A. Bridgeford, C. F. Bonney, H. E. Bartlett, L. G. Floyd, A. K. Haines, D. Hatfield, C. G. Heymann, M. J. Howes, J. B. See, E. van Greunen, and S. P. Swanepoel. Associate Members : J. Coetsee and R. P. G. Steyn. Graduates: J. J. de Villiers and J. C. King. Associates: B. J. Bucher, P. A. Combrinck, W. J. N. Gelderblom, L. S. Halasz, J. van Wyk, C. P. Visser, and A. Veress. Students: D. J. Claasens, P. C. Crous, D. H. Murchison, P. A. Rossouw, and J. P. L. Schultz. Company Affiliates: Airco Engineering (Proprietary) Limited and Deelkraal Gold Mining Company Limited. There have also been some transfers: Member to Fellow: J. B. Nangle. Graduate to Member: E. E. Eichenbergen, M. J. Hillbeck, L. A. Melis, P. J. Venter, and R. O. Wellman. Associate to Associate Member: B. M. Williams. I welcome the newly elected members to the Institute, and I congratulate those who have been transferred to a higher grade.

Jan 10, 1975

The Annual General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on Wednesday, 22nd August, 1973. Dr J. P. Hugo (President) was in the Chair. There were also present 64 Fellows, 20 Members, 5 Associates, 3 Students, and 34 Visitors, making a total of 126. The President declared the meeting open at 4.05 p.m. OBITUARIES The President: It is my sad duty to announce the death of the following members of the Institute C. Boocock, R. J. G. Moore, M. P. Pearse, and A. I. Sussman, all Fellows, and W. T. Dalling, a Life Member. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased and in sympathy with the bereaved, I ask you to rise and observe a few moments' silence. MINUTES Die President: Item twee op die agenda is die bekragtiging van die notules van die jongste Algemene Vergadering van die Instituut. Daar die notules in die Augustus uitgawe van die Joernaal gepubliseer is, vra ek u toestemming dat dit as sulks bekragtig word. Toestemming verleen. WELCOME TO VISITORS The President: It is my very great pleasure to welcome all the distinguished guests who have honoured us with their presence this afternoon; in particular, a hearty word of welcome to the Honorary President of the Institute, Mr Plumbridge, the President of the Chamber of Mines. You are doubly welcome here, sir, and we thank you for your presence. Also to that old member and stalwart, the Honorary Vice-President of the Institute, Mr Tommy Gibbs, the Government Mining Engineer-you're very welcome, Mr Gibbs. Then, we are particularly privileged this afternoon to have an Honorary Member with us, the Minister of Mines for Rhodesia, Mr Dillon. You will recall that he honoured us with his company last year. Mr Dillon, we are very appreciative and hope that this is now a standing arrangement. We are also honoured by the presence of some thirteen Presidents, Vice-Presidents, or Chairmen of our sister scientific and technical organizations. I shall rapidly read their names, but they must all feel assured that they are very welcome here today. Firstly, one of our own Past Presidents and members, Mr Geoff Goode in his capacity as President of the Associated Scientific and Technical Societies of South Africa; Mr L. R. Robinson, President of the South African Institution of Mechanical Engineers, and Mrs Robinson; Mr G. Goedhals, President of the South African Institute of Electrical Engineers ; Dr Antrobus, President of the Geological Society of South Africa, and Mrs Antrobus; Mr T. V. Dean, Vice-President of the Institute of Land Surveyors of the Transvaal, and Mrs Dean; Mr R. M. Stroh, President of the Mine Ventilation Society of South Africa; Mr Ken Steele, President of the Association of Mine Managers, and Mrs Steele; Mr Mike Gericke, President of the South African Council for Professional Engineers; Mr R. G. Matthews, President of the Institute of Mine Surveyors of South Africa; Mr P. H. Pettifor, President of the Institute of Production Engineers, London, and Mrs Pettifor ; Dr Nico Stutterheim, Chairman of the South African Institute of Chemical Engineers, and Mrs Stutterheim; Professor F. A. van Duuren, Chairman of the Engineers' Liaison Committee in Pretoria; also, I haven't spotted him but I trust he is here-Mr Alex Bain, who is Chairman of this Institute's Witbank/Middelburg Branch. To one and all, ladies and gentlemen, a hearty word of welcome. Not last on our list, a word of welcome to Mr Eric Boden, the Manager of A.S. and T.S. We also have with us I trust, Dr Deist, and his good lady-Dr Deist will be figuring in our proceedings later this afternoon. Also Mr Barcza and Mrs Barcza. Mr Bareza, a former President of the Institute, also has a task to perform. Then, I hope two of our student prize winners are here-Mr Beetge and Mr Painting. Then we also have Mr Roberts, who is welcome in his capacity as co-author with Dr Deist. Then, last of all, a hearty word of welcome to Dr Helen Glen (I am not sure whether she has arrived yet, but she is certainly due to come)-the new Honorary Editor of the Institute's Journal. MEMBERSHIP The President: I have pleasure in announcing that, their names having been published in accordance with By-law 5.2.2, the following have been elected by Council to membership in the following grades Fellows: W. G. Jayes and F. K. Wright Members: D. W. Penman, A. W. Bryson, and D. L. Gibbs Graduates: R. J. Adey, J. P. Bond, R. C. Dunne, G. M. Entwhistle, J. M. Rendu, J. P. S. Turner, and A. P. van Jaarsveld Associates: A. Ellis, B. R. Hambly, A. J. Johansen, and G. W. Tregoning

Jan 10, 1973

Colloquium and General Meeting were held at Kelvin House on 19th May, 1971, the theme being 'Modern trends in coal mining practice.' Mr V. C. Robinson (President) was in the Chair. The Colloquium was attended by 205 delegates and was opened by the President at 9 a.m. OBITUARY The President: 'It is my sad duty to announce the death of C. C. Cullen, Fellow, who joined the Institute in 1946 and passed away on 15th March, 1971. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased and in sympathy with the bereaved I would ask you all to rise and observe a few moments silence'. ELECTION OF SCRUTINEERS The President: 'In terms of Clause 9.4 of the By-Laws I now call for the nomination of seven Corporate Members to act as scrutineers of the ballot for Council'. Messrs V. C. Robinson, Prof D. D. Howat, Dr J P Hugo, D. G. Maxwell, J. K. E. Douglas, R. J. Adamson and P. Lambooy were nominated by P. W. J. van Rensburg and seconded by P. A. von Wietligh. The President: 'Are there any further nominations? If not I declare these gentlemen elected.' MEMBERSHIP The President: 'I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of candidates, having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: Members: Douglas Edward King, Bryan Rudolph Scott, James Gregor Phimister, Anthony David Walters. Graduates: Cornelius Johann Muller, Marthinus Stephanus Mulder. Associates: John George Everson, Colin Robert Llewellyn Davies. Students: Francois George Enslin Beetge, Ewald Boshoff, Christiaan J. Cloete, Christopher John Davies, Cameron George Elvin, Kenneth Eric Field, Johannes Louis Fourie, Hans Gert Gastrow, Peter John Ledger, James Robert William Lindsay, Kynaston Lloyd McDonald, Richard Peter Mohring, Arthur Leslie Painting, Matthias Arthur Pascall, Ian Neil Sinclair, Donald Allan James Ross-Watt. MEMBERS TRANSFERRED TO A HIGHER GRADE From Member to Fellow: Peter Norman Roberts. From Associate to Graduate: Alfred Eric WaIter Fletcher. From Student to Graduate: Wilfried Pierre de Villiers, Edward Emile Eichenberger, William Alan Nairn, Lodewyk Johannes de Jager, Colin Henry Obray, John Grenig Rees. COLLOQUIUM The President opened the proceedings and introduced Mr N. W. S. Schumann as the overall chairman for the day. The following papers and contributions were presented: FIRST SESSION: Chairman R. C. J. GOODE. Paper: 'Problems encountered in the operation of a new colliery' by P. M. C. Wilson and A. A. Oakes. Contributors: D. J. Moloney, G. R. Canny, I. G. Evans, R. B. MacGillivray, Dr F. G. J. de Jager, M. J. Deats, and N. Zolezzi. R. B. MacGillivray Mr President and gentlemen, I would like to congratulate the authors on presenting a most interesting paper on a very important subject. After several attempts at finding suitable reserves to extend the life of Welgedacht Exploration Company's Utrecht Colliery a block of coal rights was acquired south west of the town of Utrecht. A study of these reserves showed that they would enable a satisfactory return on capital invested to be achieved. It was decided therefore to open up what is now called the Zimbutu section of Welgedacht Exploration Company, to produce 41 000 metric tons of coal per month. The decision to open this section was taken in August, 1968 and due to certain allocation requirements it was necessary to bring it into production by the 1st of January, 1970. Fortunately a fair amount of statistical data had been collected prior to August, 1968 from the old Utrecht Colliery in anticipation of opening a mine and a fairly detailed rechnical report had been prepared. As a result the dead line was only missed by four days. Main features of the Design A feasibility study was carried out on three possible shaft positions and the final position was selected from these three on economic grounds. As the coal seam at the selected shaft position was only 21 metres below the surface it was decided to sink two twin incline shafts to enable rapid establishment of through ventilation and alternative hauling arrangements for quick development. This also allowed the final vertical ventilation shaft to be placed at some distance away to avoid the nuisance of fan noise. Second outlet requirements are also very well met by these twin inclines. Again on the basis of economics and also due to the uncertainty of roof conditions it was decided to use hand loading methods underground. However, to allow for future possible conversion to mechanised loading, should this become economical through rising wages, a conveyor belt was installed in the hauling shaft. This conveyor belt is fed from an endless rope haulage in the east companion by means of tipplers, a bin and a feeder. The main development heading was left clear for the future installation of a conveyor belt which would afford easy conversion to mechanisation.

A Colloquium and General Meeting was held jointly with the Mine Ventilation Society of S.A. in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on 17th November, 1971, the theme being "The Economics of Mine Ventilation". Professor D. Howat (President) was in the chair. The Colloquium was attended by 150 delegates and was opened by the President at 9.00 a.m. MEMBERSHIP The President: "I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the candidates, having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following Grades: Fellows: Frederich-Wilhelm Volk, Peter Bennet Columbine. Members: Allan Colin Lawrence, Karel Anton van Gessel, Christopher Robert Harrison, Christopher Michael George Wartley, Frank Heinrich Deist, Ralph Morris, Benjamin Johannes Nolte. Associates: Wolf gang Freidrich Gottsman. TRANSFERS From Member to Fellow: Hugh Edward Keith Alien. From Graduate to Member: Errol Vincent Bosman, Christopher Roderick Stewart Needes, Bernard Wessels Holthousen. From Student to Graduate: David Robert Fleming. I welcome the new members to the Institute and congratulate them on their election. CO-OPTION TO COUNCIL The President announced that at the Council meeting held on 5th October, 1971, it was agreed, in terms of Rule 3.9 to co-opt Dr T. B. Beeton to Council. COLLOQUIUM The President welcomed visitors and members. He stressed that the discussion would be informal and that any contributor requiring publication should submit his contribution in writing. He then thanked the authors for providing pre-prints of the papers. After the President had concluded his opening remarks, he asked Professor J. de V. Lambrechts to act as Colloquium Chairman for the day and he, in turn, introduced the three Session Chairmen namely, Dr A. Whillier (Chamber of Mines and President of the Mine Ventilation Society); Mr M. Barcza (Managing Director, Corner House Laboratories); and Mr L. W. P. v.d. Bosch (Chief Consulting Engineer, Union Corporation). The following papers were presented: "Fan efficiency investigation on mines of the Union Corporation, Ltd." by J. A. Drummond. Published in the Journal Feb. 1972. "The design of underground cooling towers" by A. Whilliel'. Published in the Journal, Oct. 1971. "Some aspects of the design of cooling plant installations" by R. Hemp. Published in the Journal, Nov. 1971. "The planning of ventilation and refrigeration requirements in deep mines" by D. F. H. Grave and R. M. Stroh. Published in the Journal, Dec. 1971. "Cooling power of underground environments" by D. Mitchell and A. Whillier. Published in the Journal, Oct. 1971. At the conclusion of the three technical sessions the Symposium Chairman commented as follows, indicating that he would prepare a written summing up at a later stage: "The tone of the colloquium has had a sincerely practical note about it. It would have been a pity if the ventilation experts talked only theory and little practice. This practical theme has, I am sure, made the colloquium interesting to both ventilation men and others whose daily tasks do not touch so closely on this fascinating subject. This practical theme was in evidence through all the papers and contributions. Some of you may have felt that there was not enough emphasis on the word 'economics' as advertised in the broad title of the colloquium. I do not think this was really a valid criticism because as someone said 'it all boils down to Rands in the end!' So whether it was a case of low fan efficiency, poor design of cooling towers, wrong planning or low human efficiency due to high heat stress. . . it all boils down to money saving and therefore economics, whenever improvements are forthcoming. The title of the colloquium was thus not misplaced. The views of senior mining men on the production side are appreciated. Let us say that this exchange of views between ventilation engineers and those who have to take the final decisions and spend the money, should prove to be most rewarding." Professor Lambrechts finally thanked the Session Chairmen and everybody who had helped to make the colloquium a success and the meeting closed at 4.0 p.m. In a subsequent written summing up, the Colloquium Chairman gave the following as his impressions of some of the highlights which emerged from the papers and discussion thereof: (The names indicate the authors only). Drummond: It was hinted that the time had arrived to consider the introduction of a South African fan test code which would be better suited to local conditions than the currently acknowledged B.S.S. code which, however, is seldom enforceable in practice. In this connection also, there was prominent reference to the thermodynamic approach of McPherson. Wide variations in the quality of maintenance of, and repair work on, fans were stressed. It was mooted that ventilation engineers responsible for estimating the basic duty specifications for large fans, frequently played safe by overestimating the pressure required, thus ensuring that there would not be a shortfall in air volume delivered. This usually meant reduced fan efficiency and it was suggested that decision makers seemed to lay more emphasis on volume of air delivered than on real eco-

Statistical summary of the mineral industry world production, exports and imports 1964-1969 Published by Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, on behalf of the Institute of Geological Sciences (1971) The Statistical Summary contains a wealth of care fully garnered information on the production, exports and imports of the principal minerals and mineral products throughout the world for the period 1964-1969, and it should therefore be of particular interest to economic geologists and others concerned with marketing and selling minerals. In view of the intractable nature of the source data it is quite an achievement to have published figures for 1969 so expeditiously. On picking up the Summary this reviewer instinctively compared it with the Annual Yearbook published by the United States Department of the Interior. The Yearbooks have been issued annually since 1882, and today each consists of a set of three separate books containing five volumes. Apart from abundant statistics on the domestic and international mineral industries, the Yearbooks are known for their perspicacious reviews and articles on a host of different facets of the world's minerals industry. Physically the Summary is a much slimmer publication than the Yearbook, and it contains no commentary whatsoever other than occasional footnotes. The principal contents are a series of tables showing production, exports and imports of fifty-nine of the world's more important minerals and mineral products. Each table shows the weight of the material produced or traded, by countries, with figures for each of the six years in adjoining columns. In some cases (e.g. diamonds) values in British currency are quoted in addition to weights. Most of the data have been abstracted from national reports and returns, although in some instances estimates are quoted where national sources are silent--as for example the production of platinum in South Africa. One wonders in passing if any useful purpose is served by the continued suppression of this particular figure. The four South African producers must surely be able to estimate each other's production fairly accurately by now, and one imagines that the national export figures can likewise be synthesised. This reviewer has two minor criticisms of an otherwise praiseworthy publication. Firstly it seems an unnecessary anachronism to perpetuate the split between 'Commonwealth' and 'Other' countries-the split can have little practical significance today. Secondly, what is one to make of the statement that the 1966-1969 figures for exports from Rhodesia of chrome ore and copper, to take two examples only, are 'not available'? It seems improbable that no estimates of these figures have been made since the imposition of sanctions, and inevitably one suspects that the figures have been excluded on policy grounds. Hopefully this problem will have been solved when the next Summary is published. M.J.M. South Africa, land of Challenge by Maurice Tyack France Interpresse, 323 pages, price R18-00. Is South Africa God's richest acre? In its mineral wealth it certainly is, but what of the many other complex overlays of emotions, traditions and racial problems? South Africa, Land of Challenge, provides the background. This is reported to be the first comprehensive documentary work of its kind on South Africa. It is a handsome volume measuring 12ft by 9f', is illustrated by at least 600 photographs of South Africa, more than half of which are in colour, and contains 21 original maps and charts. The book covers the full spectrum of South Africa's very existence, its geography, pre-history, its customs, countryside, natural resources and its cities. The more controversial categories are thoroughly discussed, the people, their policies and politics. Mr Tyack is eminently qualified to write on South Africa, being the author of over 20 books on other African countries and having spent more than three years of research, in the field, in South African archives and also in various libraries and museums, in preparation for this book. The book claims to be free of any party political bias and appears to be an honest attempt at a factual survey. However, a work of this magnitude will undoubtedly leave an impression on the reader and the tone of this book is decidedly patriotic. This is a useful reference work on South Africa that most South Africans will be proud to own. J.P.H. Ergonomics and physical environmental factors This publication by I.L.O. of a symposium in Rome in September 1968 has much useful information for the mining industry in regard to the health and productivity of its labour force. The first subject dealt with is mechanical vibrations. From this section it is clear that men who drive, for many hours each day, vehicles which vibrate in the 6 Hz range are subject to serious physiological and psychological effects. The former may show as changes to the vertebral column (which has a resonance in the 4-5 Hz range). The circulatory system is adversely effected by values in the 6-10 Hz range and the vision is impaired at between 40-100 Hz. Less definite knowledge exists of the effects of vibration on the hand-arm system from mechanical drills etc, although Raynauds disease of the blood vessels of the hand and degenerative diseases of the elbow and shoulder joints occur in men using drills which vibrate, respectively, in the higher and low frequency ranges. Industrial noise is extremely well dealt with and the latest knowledge is summarized. Clear information is given on the relationship between time of exposure to

The May General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg on 20th May, at 4.30 p.m. Mr V. C. Robinson (Vice-President) was in the Chair in the absence, overseas, of the President, Mr J. K. E. Douglas. There were also present 16 Fellows: Messrs J. A. Adamson, R. S. J. du Toit, J. A. Drummond, D. F. A. Grave, T. L. Gibbs, G. H. Grange, D. V. Howat, P. H. Kitto, Dr P. J. LIoyd, Messrs B. H. L. Leach, J. de V. Lambrechts, Dr J. T. McIntyre, Messrs C. S. MacPhail, P. W. van Rensburg, S. G. Taussig, W. S. Rapson. Six Members: Messrs E. L. Atkinson, R. Hemp, Dr J. Martinson, Messrs A. H. Munro, G. J. van Jaarsveld and J. H. Qwilliam. Two Associate Members: Messrs B. H. van Rensburg and H. Triiter. Four Visitors: Prof J. E. Kerrich, Dr G. K. Sluis-Cremer, Messrs D. Kisbey-Green and L. W. Isserow. For Secretariat: Mrs S. de Gersigny. Total present: 27. OBITUARY The Vice-President: "It is my sad duty to announce the death of Stephen Ring, a member who joined the Institute in ]961, and passed away on the 31st of December, 1969. I would ask you all to rise and observe a moment's silence. Thank you." MINUTES The Vice-President: "May we confirm the minutes of the Special General Meeting and Monthly General Meeting, held on 20th February, 1970, as published in the April issue of the Journal?" MEMBERSHIP The Vice-President: "I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the undermentioned candidates, having been published in accordance with By-Law 5 2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: Fellows: Denis Ian Field, Arthur Cecil Waiter Comyn, John Hall, Leon VercueiI. Members: Jan McLellan Vosloo, Jan van Velze. Graduates: Richard Darnley Beck, John Edward Andrews, Roderick Nowell Randell. Associates: Alexander Duncan Ross, Ian James Terrill. Students: Hendrik Jacobus Oostenwald Prins Smith, Graham Peter Gooding, Rudannes Raath Homan. "I welcome the newly, elected members to the Institute." GENERAL BUSINESS The Vice-President: "Are there any matters which you wish to raise under 'General'? There being no matters to raise under 'General', we will proceed to the next item on the Agenda." PAPER FOR PRESENTATION The Vice-President: "It is my pleasant duty to call on Dr du Toit to deliver his paper, entitled, 'The functional relationship between dust hazard and the rate of collecting funds to pay compensation for pneumoconiosis'." After the presentation of the paper (published in the March Journal) the Vice-President said: "This paper is a very important addition to the considerable volume of work applications on this subject of pneumoconiosis. The disease, in all its various forms, has received attention from many, many great men, both in the medical world, and engineers. The fact that there is this big volume of publications of literature on it still doesn't mean that we can get anywhere beyond the old, simple injunction, that the prevention of pneumoconiosis does not depend on compensation, levies or anything else. It simply depends on allaying dust as quickly as possible. "This paper, however, is another scientific landmark and I think, in a cold and dispassionate way, it sets out some important points in this whole subject of the relationship of the levy - the money of compensation to the dust which causes it. "I have, personally, very little to criticise in this paper but when I listened to Dr du Toit's final conclusions, I wondered whether the words, 'Within the data available', aren't the key to this whole situation. I agree that he has demonstrated a workable relationship between the current industries for levy and dustiness, but among the factors which he lists as being important, I know that there is one which is missing. This is extremely difficult to evaluate. It's a factor which has destroyed, on so many occasions, the work which has been done by so many genuine, intent, honest people working in this field, and this is this unknown factor, this hidden factor of political opportunism, which has so often played a very important part in pneumoconiosis compensation. "How many of us have seen the grubby, grasping fingers of power-mad demagogues, and I can name them for you - but I won't - and also the blatant vote-catching of certain politicians interfering in this field. How, at the end of all that, the poor scientist, the poor dedicated man in the Mines' Department, who has to write the law of compensation, can operate, I do not know. "From this picture the ordinary layman recoils in horror. Among the casualties in this particular war, which has been fought over so many years, I am perfectly certain, are some of the criteria of certification, especially in '56/,57, when that extraordinary condition, known as 'pulmonary disability' was introduced. I am sure there were casualties then, in the criteria of certification. "Nevertheless, this paper is a worthy addition to the long list of scientific work done on this so-important

The November General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on Wednesday, 18th November, 1970, at 4.00 p.m. V. C. Robinson (President) was in the Chair. There were also present 30 Fellows, including J. K. E. Douglas, R. C. J. Goode, Dr J. P. Hugo, Prof J. de V. Lambrechts, D. G. Maxwell, Prof R. P. Plewman, Dr M. D. G. Salamon, P. W. J. van Rensburg, L. W. P. van den Bosch (Council Members), R. E. Burnton, S. Craib, D. de Villiers Oxford, J. C. Fritz, G. W. Gray, G. H. Henderson, S. D. Hill, C. H. Kruger, B. Leach, C. S. MacPhail, D. J. Molony, W. G. Fyne Mercier, R. A. Scott, M. v. R. Steyn, I. E. van Aswegan, A. D. Vos, J. M. Vosloo and N. Zolezzi. Four Members, including I. G. Evans, R. W. Shearer, W. Wilson. One Associate: P. M. C. Wilson. Four Students: H. G. Albertyn, J. T. Davies, P. G. Henderson and P. J. Pretorius. Fourteen Visitors, including S. R. Barker, F. H. Deist, Dr de Jager, L. F. Duvel, P. du P. Kruger, B. D. Maree, B. R. Meyer, R. Redmond, J. Rietief, A. W. S. Schumann, Mrs A. W. S. Schumann, T. S. Stoffberg, C. A. Visser and R. van der Wait. Secretary, D. C. Visser. Total present 55. The President: "Gentlemen, I would like to welcome all members of the Institute who are present, and visitors, and I would like specially to welcome any members of the Suid-Afrikaanse Akademie who are present this afternoon." OBITUARIES The President: "Before starting on the agenda the first item, of course, is unfortunately obituaries and it is my sad duty to announce the death of the following: I would like to start with a person who is not actually a member of the Institute but who, in his capacity as President of the Chamber of Mines, was Honorary President of this Institute three times and I refer, of course, to Mr Herman Calderwood Koch who passed away last Saturday. Then I would refer to Richard Beaumont Tasker, Life Fellow, who joined this Institute in 1932, and who died on the 22nd of October, 1970. Then, lastly, Mr Jean Francois du Plessis, a student, who joined the Institute on the 19th June, 1968, and passed away on the 11th of November, 1970, as the result of an accident. Mr du Plessis was to have received a Student Prize today for his paper entitled, Displacements and stresses in the vicinity of a horizontal long-wall'. We were all most upset to learn of his death last week, and we are now going to make arrangements to hand his prize to his widow on a suitable special occasion. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased, and in sympathy with the bereaved, I would ask you all to stand and observe a few moments' silence. Thank you." CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES The President: "May we confirm the minutes of the monthly general meeting which was held on 16th September, 1970, as published in the November Journal?" Agreed. MEMBERSHIP The President: "I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the undermentioned candidates having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2, Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: Fellow: Ronald White Ballantine. Members: Jan Johannes Hertzog Viljoen, Agge Petrus Rutgerus van der Meer, Peter Anthony Reynolds, Ernest Esdaile Leyde Hans Lutz Klingmann, Ronald Archer.' Graduates: Trevor Stanley Schultz, Thomas Cochrane Meiklejohn, Leslie Harold Heyman, Dennis William Bosch, Sydney Stuart Absolom. Associates:Roderick James.Vermaak, Theodorus Daniel van Wyk, Michael Osmond Savignac Stedman, Leslie Owen Raymer, Bryan Arthur McKay, Leon Ellis Finlay Leask, Dudley Graham Lovedren Hall, John Arthur Gibbon, Richard Reginald de Villiers, Carel Frederik Boshoff. Students: Frederik Wilhelm Christian Coetzer, Phillippus Johannes de Wit, Jan van der Merwe Grimes, Davood Khareghani, Jan Wolvaardt Oberholzer, Johannes Lodewikus Pretorius Pieter Jacobus Strobos, Herbert Gerald Waldeck.' MEMBERS TRANSFERRED TO A HIGHER GRADE From Associate to Fellow: Howard Mitchell Wells. From Associate to Member: Ernest John Dominy. "I welcome the newly elected members to the Institute and congratulate the members who have been transferred to a higher grade." AWARDS The President: "It is with very great pleasure that I can announce that Council has agreed to make the following awards for papers presented to the Institute during the year ended July, 1970. Gold Medals to Prof Plewman and W. D. Ortlepp for their paper entitled 'The development and application of a digital computer method for the solution of strata control problems' written jointly with F. H. Deist (Visitor) and presented in September, 1969. A Silver Medal to Dr Finkelstein for his paper entitled 'The Influence of sulphydryl and cationic flotation reagents on cyanidation of native gold' written jointly with Dr K. G. Ashurst (Visitor), and presented in June 1969 at the Symposium on the Recovery of Pyrite. ' May I congratulate these gentlemen on the high honour they have won with their papers. As new medals are in the process of being designed the actual awards will be made at a later date to be announced to members.

The Annual General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on Wednesday, August 14th, 1974. Mr P. W. J. van Rensburg (President) was in the Chair. There were present 56 Fellows, 21 Members, 2 Graduates, 5 Associates, 16 Students, and 58 Visitors, making a total of 158. The President declared the Meeting open at 4.08 p.m. OBITUARIES The President: Ladies and gentlemen, before we start the business of the meeting, it is my sad duty to announce the deaths of the following members of the Institute since our last meeting: Dr O. A. E. Jackson, Honorary Life Fellow and Past President; C. Airth, T. L. Blunt, A. E. Frazer, C. L. Lamb, and K. Richardson, Life Fellows; and J. T. Beaumont, Fellow. As you know, there were a number of other deaths during the year, which were reported at previous General Meetings of the Institute. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased, and in sympathy with the bereaved, I ask you to rise and observe a few moments' silence. MINUTES The President: Ladies and gentlemen, the next item on your agenda is confirmation of the minutes of the General Meeting and Special General Meeting held on May 22nd, 1974. These will be published in the August issue of the Journal, and, since you have not yet received this, I must ask that they be held over to the next General Meeting. WELCOME The President: It is a very pleasant duty for me to welcome many members of our Institute and our guests, among whom we are particularly pleased to see the President of the Chamber of Mines, Mr Dolf Schumann, who is also Honorary President of this Institute. Mr Schumann, we are extremely pleased to have you with us today. And, we welcome an old friend of ours, Mr Dillon, Minister of Mines in Rhodesia, who has come down for our Annual General Meeting. Mr Dillon, we are very, very pleased to see you here this evening, and we look forward to seeing Mrs Dillon a little later. And we have with us, too, the presidents or representatives of many of our sister and brother associations, institutes, and societies. In particular, we welcome Mr Mike Gericke, President of the South African Council of Professional Engineers, and Professor Midgley, President of A. S. and T. S. We are also pleased to welcome the Presidents of the Mechanical Engineers, Electrical Engineers, Certificated Mechanical and Electrical Engineers, the Civil Engineers, the Joint Council of Scientific Societies, the Mine Ventilation Society, the South African Association of Consulting Engineers, the Association of Mine Managers, the Institute of Foundrymen, the Institute of Welding, the Federation of Societies of Professional Engineers, Mine Surveyors, Production Engineers (London), and the Institute of Production Engineering. We are very glad, too, to have with us a visitor from England, Professor Raynor and Mrs Raynor. Professor Raynor is Professor of Metallurgy at Birmingham University, and a very well-known metallurgist in Britain. We also have with us the Chairman of the Ferro-Alloys Association. We are expecting the Chairman of our Witbank/Middelburg Branch, the Chairman of the Engineers' Liaison Committee, Pretoria, the Director of the Witwatersrand College of Technical Education, and, of course, our old friend, Mr Eric Boden, the Manager of A.S. and T.S. It is a very great pleasure to have with us a number of persons who will receive honorary Life Fellowship at this meeting, and there are some Gold Medal winners and winners of our Student Prizes. We have apologies from a number of people who are away on business, and unfortunately some are ill. But we are extremely pleased to see those of you who are here, and we are also very pleased to see so many ladies. We expect to see many more of them later this evening, at our Cocktail Party. MEMBERSHIP The President: I have pleasure in announcing that, their names having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2., the following have been elected by Council to membership in the following grades Fellows: B. Collins, D. W. Dixon, J. P. Dreyer, A. T. Hudson, and W. W. Pearce. Members: A. T. Fisher and I. F. Nagy. Associate Members : P. D. de Bruyn and H. C. Iverson. Graduates: D. P. O'Shaugnessy and M. F. Sadler. Associates: R. J. Bushell and A. MacDonald. Students : I. J. Barker, P. J. Charter, J. P. de Witt, G. S. Esterhuizen, N. Green, P. M. Jenner, M. J. R. Meyer, A. P. Nicol, W. J. C. Pothas, B. J. Robbetze, N. T. Sutherland, B. A. Statham, C. R. Thomas, N. C. Webb, M. Salamon, R. G. Jurd, and M. McChesney. Transfers to other grades of membership include the following: Member to Fellow: B. W. Holtzhousen. Graduate to Member: T. S. Schultz. Associate to Associate Member: C. L. Jordaan, H. J. L. Tomlinson, J. E. Forbes, G. H. S. Bamford, T. F. Carswell, J. W. Breidenhann, J. R. Garbutt, and L. S. Gibbs. Student to Graduate: C. J. Faueonnier and B. Lund. Student to Associate : G. P. Gooding. We welcome these new members

Jan 10, 1974

The October General Meeting of the Institute was held in Kelvin House, Johannesburg, on Wednesday, 21st October, 1970, at 4.30 p.m. V. C. Robinson (President) was in the chair. There were also present 25 Fellows, including J. K. E. Douglas, Prof D. D. Howat, D. G. Maxwell, Dr R. E. Robinson, P. A. von Wielligh (Council Members). D. Ayres, G. Burrow, E. H. D. Carman, D. L. Carson, M. E. E. Douglas, S. A. Finney, W. R. Flook, A. J. Freemantle, W. A. Gilbert, E. B. Gordon, B. W. Gray, J. M. Jacobs, P. H. Kitto, C. H. Kruger, Dr P. J. D. Lloyd, D. G. Malan, W. Pilkington, W. G. Pyne-Mercier, K. S. Rae, W. T. Ruhmer, D. J. Tutt and D. T. Watt. Seven Members, including E. J. Dominy, S. I. du Preez, L. V. Grobler, D. R. Lings, G. D. Louw, J. S. A. Oelofse and O. B. Prentis. Fifteen Visitors, including J. R. Coppin, Dr A. Faure, P. E. Franzl, G. P. Hart, D. van Heerden, A. W. Hunt, A. R. F. MacDonald, B. G. Meyburgh, P. H. Radcliffe, J. M. Shirley, T. H. Tunley, A. D. Vellema and R. E. Wheeler. Secretary, D. C. Visser. Total present: 49. OBITUARIES The President: "It is my sad duty to announce the death of the following: Sir George Arthur Davenport, Honorary Life Fellow, who joined the Institute in 1930 and passed away on 17th September, 1970. The late Sir George was also, for many years, our corresponding member for Rhodesia. Andrew Malcolm Carmichael, Associate, who joined the Institute in 1944 and passed away on 22nd August, 1970. Cyril John Douglas Veal, Life Fellow, who joined the Institute in 1929 and passed away on 27th August, 1970. As a mark of respect to the memory of the deceased and in sympathy with the bereaved I would ask you all to rise and observe a few moments' silence." CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES The President: "May we confirm the minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on 26th August, 1970, and the minutes of the monthly general meetings which were held on the 20th of May and the 17th of June, 1970, as published in the August Journal." Agreed. MEMBERSHIP The President: "I have much pleasure in announcing that the names of the undermentioned candidates, having been published in accordance with By-Law 5.2.2., Council has elected them to membership of the Institute in the following grades: Members: Nikolaos Lalakakis, Gordon Phillips Rundle. Associates: Henry du Preez, James Robert Forbes, Johannes Stephanus Albertus Oelofse, Casper Vorster van Heerden. Graduates: Michael Harold Crosbie, Graham Robert Wallis Walker, Gary Walker Braithwaite. Students: Mohammad Ali Kazemzadeh, Gerhardus Petrus Benade. APPLICATIONS FOR TRANSFER From Graduate to Member: James Wormald. From Student to Graduate: Peter John Cook, Pieter Willem Greeff. "I welcome the newly elected members to the Institute and congratulate the members who have been transferred to a higher grade." PAPER FOR PRESENTATION The President: "This paper is entitled 'The Design, Erection and Operation of a Purlex Plant at Buffelsfontein Gold Mining Company Limited'. It is presented to the Institute by Mr B. G. Meyburgh, a visitor to our Institute. He is a graduate of the University of the Orange Free State and is the Uranium Plant Superintendent at Buffelsfontein and he, therefore, is in a very strong position to describe this very excellent job which is being done as he has been associated with this plant from the inception." After the presentation of the paper the President said: "Gentlemen, the paper you've heard from Mr Meyburgh is a very concise and interesting account of an important piece of work, and I think the title is so completely descriptive of the subject, which is admirably set out in the paper which you have heard. You probably haven't all had the opportunity of reading it, but you very soon will. I found it interesting to note that the results predicted were surpassed in the operation of the plant to date. The actual results obtained are significantly good, I think. Any process which, in this country, increases production and decreases costs, is to be welcomed, particularly when it is so necessary for South Africa almost to bend over backwards to utilise every avenue available in order to increase the scope of the production for overseas' markets, of her metallurgical and mineral potential. In lighter vein-and there is no reason why we should always be so serious-I am glad to see that, in a scientific journal like this, such words as the American word 'crud' which I have been picked out about so often, because my grandchildren use it, is now given an aura of respectability. Thank you very much, Mr Meyburgh, for an interesting paper. We have a long list of contributors, and I am not going to waste any more time. I am going to call on Mr Tunley of the N.I.M. for the first contribution." T. H. Tunley, P. de Bruyn (read by A. D. Vellema), E. J. Dominy, E. H. D. Carman, A. R. F. MacDonald D. C. Streicher (read by P. H. Radcliff), Dr A. Faure and Dr P. J. D. Lloyd then contributed to the discussion. (This discussion will appear in a later issue of the Journal.) The President: "I wish to thank members and visitors for their attendance, and now declare the meeting closed." The meeting closed at 6.05 p.m.

By M. I. Brittan

Discussion Dr R. E. Robinson (Fellow): The author must be congratulated on a very meticulous and self-contained piece of work. It is indeed a pleasure to read a paper that is so clearly and systematically laid out, and where the conclusions and the testwork conducted have been so clearly described. The paper is complete in itself, which makes it very difficult for someone who is not intimately involved in the whole Torco project to make any comments on its content. However, two points that, strictly speaking, fall outside the scope of the paper are of considerable interest. The first relates to the particle size of the material treated. In the paper, the testwork is confined to one standard particle size (minus 60 plus 100 mesh). The essential feature of the paper is to indicate that the rate-controlling reaction in the whole segregation process is the rate of reaction of the ore particles with the reducing agent and the hydrogen chloride. One wonders, therefore, to what extent this relatively slow rate of reaction is affected by the particle size of the ore itself. One imagines that the reaction must take place by contact of the hydrogen chloride with the surface of the mineral particles, and it is reasonable to suspect that the rate of diffusion of the copper ions to the surface is a relatively slow process and is thus the limiting factor in this particular rate of reaction. It is possible, for example, that the improvement obtained, when the ore is subjected to reducing conditions before the chlorination, is due to a breakdown in the crystal structure of the original particle. This breakdown is brought about by the reduction and by the consequent increase in surface area available for reaction with hydrogen chloride. Can the author indicate whether any work has been done along these lines, and whether it has been established that the reaction depends on the surface area available? The second point relates to the application of this kinetic study to the actual operation of a Torco reactor. It was once planned to feed the sodium chloride, together with the reducing agent, into the top of the segregation chamber. In the paper, the author mentions that it has now been established that the segregation chamber behaves, to all intents and purposes, as a fluidized bed, and that there is, therefore, a rapid evolution of gas in the lower regions of the chamber, which, it is imagined, displaces the gas phase rapidly. Since the reaction between sodium chloride, water vapour, and the aluminium silicates in the ore is extremely rapid, one wonders how much of the hydrogen chloride produced is removed from the reaction zone before it has had time to react with the copper minerals. The extremely low consumption of sodium chloride (which is a vital feature of the Torco process) must depend on an extremely rapid circulation of the hydrogen chloride gas to all the ore particles in the segregation chamber. One wonders, therefore, if a system for the introduction of the sodium chloride into the bottom regions of the chamber might not result in even greater efficiency in the utilization of sodium chloride. ProC D. D. Howat (Fellow): All of us who have been concerned with the study of chemical reactions at high temperatures are keenly interested in kinetics and are well aware that this is not an easy study experimentally. Dr. Brittan is to be congratulated on the development of neat experimental methods and for his full discussion of the results obtained. Although the segregation process for the extraction of copper from oxide and silicate ores has been known for almost fifty years, the fundamental chemical and physical changes involved have been little understood and the fundamental data are very scanty. The work now in progress at A.A.R.L., together with that sponsored by the Anglo American Corporation in other research institutions throughout the world, is bound to produce new fundamental data and a much more complete understanding of this rather fascinating process. It is already apparent that some of the old and well-worn chemical reactions that were postulated to occur, just cannot take place in the way which was formerly accepted. Dr Brittan's work, carefully conducted and thoroughly analyzed as it has been, still leaves us with one great outstanding problem. The thermodynamic data and the possible reactions set out in Table I (page 281) of his paper leave us asking, in complete despair, how can copper be converted into a volatile chloride in the presence of HCl, CO and carbon at temperatures about 800°C? The thermodynamics all combine to show that copper should be reduced to metal as the first step in the process. This brings us right up against the second problem. If copper were reduced to the metal how would HCI convert it to the volatile chloride? On top of these problems is the unknown reason for the very high speed of reaction between CO, HCI and the ground copper ore. Still further into the region of the unknown is the reaction by which gaseous hydrochloric acid is produced in the actual process. Perhaps Dr Brittan is feeling grateful that he doesn't have to try to explain this reaction-at this stage of the research programme at least. The results very clearly show that both CO and HCl gas are essential for rapid production of the volatile copper chloride. Dr Brittan states that 18 minutes were required to attain 83 per cent extraction with HCl gas alone and this was reduced to 4 minutes when CO was

Jan 2, 1970

By G. A. Wiebols, N. G. W. Cook, N. C. Joughin

Discussion R. E. Rarnes (Member): The original concepts and the pioneering work now brought to the practical test stage by the Mining Research Laboratory team deserve our highest praise. The authors of this comprehensive paper rightly stress the urgency of establishing the extent to which the apparent potential can profitably be realised in practice. It is to be hoped that adequate funds will be made available by individual mining companies, the Chamber of Mines and manufacturers to attract the necessary staff and maintain the high rate of achievement of the last two years. From the Seventy-Eighth Annual Report of the Chamber of Mines and its members we see that, in 1967, with a Working Revenue of R759.8 million from gold and R54.6 million pit mouth coal sales and with profits from gold and uranium and pyrite of R307.9 million, only R1.9 million was spent by the Chamber on all forms of Research. It is considered unlikely that the associated mining companies and manufacturers exceeded this investment expenditure. Assuming a total of R4 million spent by the industry on Research and Development, this is less than half of 1 per cent of sales of gold and coal. This percentage, so low in comparison to North America and Europe, is no worse than that of Exploration expenditure which, in 1967, with South Africa's total mineral production of R1,287 million, was estimated to have been R6 million (Pretorius 1968). In a primary industry with ever present depletion of ore deposits and with cost escalation, expenditure on Exploration and on Research and Development is not a risky luxury but a tactical obligation. The potential rate of return on research expenditure into rock breaking is high. Stores consumed by gold and coal mines, members of the Chamber of Mines, totalled R316.2 million in 1967. Except for purchased power costing R42.2 million the highest cost group was explosives, drills and drill steel totalling R33.8 million or 10.7 per cent of the total stores consumed. In the paper under discussion it is claimed that the low 'effective stoping width' should greatly reduce the likelihood of rock falls or rock bursts to the extent that permanent support can be dispensed with. Insofar as this narrow cut is only 12 in. in advance of the working area which, with a 10 in. channel, is unlikely to be much reduced in width from that achieved by current methods, this claim is not readily understandable. Were it to have been based upon the regional support gained from packed waste it would have been more acceptable. Pre-developed stope drives may give serious trouble at depth and for this reason it is questioned whether a stoping area can avoid periodic sub-development blasting-the spoil and fumes from which will interfere with the rock flow and continuous mining of the rock-cutter. If, in the mining method proposed by the authors, stope drives are cut as small as possible (6 ft by 6 ft) then 25 per cent of the total tons handled (excluding resued waste) and 5 per cent of the gold will be blasted conventionally in the stope. At this stage one cannot envisage tunnelling machines economically or practically capable of such work. The various methods described by the authors and subsequent contributors for breaking waste are most interesting. It was noted that the 'bull wedge' and 'explosives' in Fig. 1 of the paper were no further from the ideal point 'A' than was 'cutting'. The writer considers that the bold and imaginative steps taken by the Mining Research Laboratory Team, the mining companies and the manufacturers concerned will eventually lead to a successful rock cutting machine with universal application largely independent of rock type. This may take many years. In the meantime other methods of improving productivity of saleable metal by rock breaking teams should be investigated even if such methods have local applications only. In 1955 the writer conducted tests with a wire saw similar to those used in quarries in the Northern Transvaal and elsewhere. Jeppestown shale, the immediate footwall of much of the East Rand gold field, was cut at the rate of 6 in. per hour using sand, water and a special endless rope driven by a low h.p. motor. A hypothesis on its application was submitted to the Office of the Government Mining Engineer in 1955 and to other mining institutions in 1966 after the writer returned to South Africa. By inference, rope sawing was classed as less promising than other methods tested in the Orange Free State Goldfields (Parker 1969). With highly resilicified hanging and footwall quartzites this was not surprising and confirmed the writers findings when testing hanging wall quartzite from the East Rand in 1955. The relatively uniform conditions, the low strength, hardness, and silica content of the Merensky Reef platinum deposits (Gray and von Bardeleben 1969) and in particular, the existence of overlying Merensky pyroxenite (Cousins 1964) make this and the East Rand attractive areas for larger scale testing of wire saws. It is envisaged that in suitable rock types the 5/8 in. slot would be advanced down dip or down a minor dip. In undisturbed areas 'faces' of up to 200 ft in length could be cut several feet in advance of breaking which could then consist of light blasting to the second free face or some of the methods now being tested for breaking waste in rock-cutting operations. A wire saw is an inexpensive and simple machine which, in some areas, could make significant and early gains in rock breaking efficiency as well as in ground and stoping width control.

Jan 5, 1968